why is adverse possession rare in california

why is adverse possession rare in california

Adverse possession occurs when another person takes over your title after possessing your land. With one of the largest real estate markets country, California is the perfect place for people wanting to own a home. Its important to consult with a qualified real estate attorney if you are facing a potential adverse possession claim or have questions about your property rights. What are the proposed changes to L.A. outdoor dining permits? At FindLaw.com, we pride ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and resources on the web. In California, adverse possession laws allow for a person to legally claim ownership over a property by paying taxes and staying there for a certain amount of time. In Woodward v. Adverse possession is the process of getting the title to a property by continuous possession for a prescribed period of time. That determination is based on the recognition that an easement involves shared usage rather than a dispossession of the true owner. Either way, you'll need to learn about California's adverse possession laws. Still, squatting can be treated as criminal behavior if the property owner or landlord has established that the individual in question is unwelcome. There must be uninterrupted and continuous possession for at least five years. In the recent case of Hagman v. Meher Mount Corporation, the Court carved out an exception to when taxes need to be paid. Adverse possession is a principle of real estate law that allows a person who possesses land belonging to another person for an extended period of time, to claim legal ownership of the land. Firms. The easiest way to remember the distinction is that adverse possession is a claim to complete ownership of the property. An owner may also file a lawsuit against a neighbor for a restraining order, an injunction, and a declaratory judgment, among other remedies. There is no single statute in the Golden State that dictates the elements that a trespasser must establish to prove adverse possession. Depending on how one looks at it, adverse possession can either seem like an unfair theft of land by squatters or a justified grant to someone who will actually put the property to good use. Of course, there are some hurdles to clear before someone can claim a piece of your California land using this theory. To establish title by adverse possession, the claimant must prove that he occupied the subject property in an open and notorious fashion, that his possession was hostile to the owners title, that the claimant claimed the property as his own, that possession was continuous and uninterrupted for five years, and that he paid all of the real property taxes levied against the property during those years. The adverse possessor must be the only person to use the property during the required time period. In any situation where the neighbor will not stop using the owners land, the owner should seek the advice of a real estate attorney. Requirements of adverse possession include exclusive use, continuous use and open takeover of the land. There must be uninterrupted and continuous possession for at least five years. This concept is spread throughout Europe as well to this day. It has been kept alive in order to achieve a fair result when one owner left a piece of land idle or unused, while another has been tending to it for so long that to make him or her leave would seem unfair, or create hardship. Its possible that someone, such as a neighbor, stranger, trespasser, or tenant, could take your land through adverse possession. The most frequent defense to any lawsuit for adverse possession or a prescriptive easement is for the owner to establish that he consented to the claimants use during the 5-year period of occupancy. Most track homes in California have fences around their backyards establishing boundaries, unlike other states, such as Michigan. The court decided that Roberto did not have the authority to sell the property, which meant that Sunols deed was ineffective, and he tried to assert the fledgling concept of adverse possession. [Read More], It is after Labor Day weekend and that means school supplies, summer vacation credit card bills, and preparing for the holidays. The squatter must prove that they have resided in the property for an uninterrupted amount of time. Its not uncommon for property owners to be unsure about their property rights. The email address cannot be subscribed. 2023 Thomas Whitelaw All Rights Reserved, Disclaimer| Site Map| Privacy Policy |Business Development Solutions by FindLaw, part of Thomson Reuters, Adverse possession in the state of California, Err in an honest manner (such as relying on an erroneous deed), Merely occupy the land (whether they do or dont know that it is private property). Q: My neighbor put an incorrect fence up 10 years ago about a foot in the property line. The California law allows a squatter to claim possession of a house after establishing his or her residency by having mail and bills sent to the house, openly coming and going through the. 824 (1962) Property was deeded to three sons but only one son farmed the land. The years passfive years, in fact. Part of this exemption resulted in Meher Mount being exempt from taxation, including for property taxes. Who Is Considered a Squatter in California? Show the property title with your name listed. You must have paid the taxes on the disputed property. Learn more about FindLaws newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy. If they remain in possession of it for a specified number of years, they can make a legal claim in court for the title. What should you do if you spot a trespasser or a neighbor encroaching on your California land? It must be continuous over a period of time. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously. Property taxes are usually assessed based on the legal description of a property, not on where the parties have located their fences. If you or a loved one has been involved in an adverse possession claim we invite you to contact us at Pride Legalfor legal counseling or any further questions. the occupation or possession of land by a person not legally entitled to it. California works in favor of the landlord or landowner (as long as they have not abandoned the property or failed to maintain it). The court may then issue a cease and desist order against the neighbor. This can diffuse their adverse possession claim, but it does make getting rid of them significantly harder. Palo Alto Real Estate Lawyer, Bay Area Real Estate Lawyer, Lending Law, Purchase Transactions, Foreclosure Law, Bankruptcy, Insurance Matters. Adverse possession under a claim of written instrument or judgment is present in those cases where (1) the land has been usually cultivated or improved, (2) where it has been protected by a substantial inclosure, (3) where, although not inclosed, it has been used for the supply of fuel, or of fencing timber for the purposes of husbandry, or for For one, the burden of proof is on the trespasser. Ideally, the owner should have the neighbor countersign that letter. Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. Open & Notorious using the property as the owner would and not hiding his/her occupancy. Some states have measures for color of title. You can present this judgment to the local sheriff (not the police), and the sheriff will post a writ of execution which the squatter will then have five days to move out. This is done without lawful permission. Even the Highest Tech Business Operations Require a Human Touch, My Top Five Investor Tips for Serious Real Estate Investors, Mentoring Series Step 4 - Attracting Participants, How to Breathe New Life into a Stale Listing. Though perhaps counter-intuitive, such action helps solidify the adverse user's "hostile" claim for a prescriptive easement, or adverse possession if he also pays the taxes. The following are the four major elements that make an adverse possession claim valid. The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. To establish title this way, a person must prove all of the following: (Click this hyperlink to read the complete opinion in the Hansen case at Justia.) You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Even though squatters do have rights in general, they can be arrested as a criminal trespasser if they do not fulfill the requirements for adverse possession. Adverse possession occurs when a person, or for example a squatter who has found a home to live in. That exclusion is inconsistent with the joint use of the land. You can do your own research and find more general information on this topic in FindLaws adverse possession section. For example, in the illuminating case of Nielsen v. Gibson (178 Cal.App.4th 318), one aspect of the owners defense against a claimants action for adverse possession was that she was in Ireland throughout the 5 years and therefore did not have reasonable notice of the occupation. 1. Adverse possession essentially allows a trespasser onto a piece of land to gain ownership of that land if the true owner fails to object within a certain period of time and if the trespasser pays faithful property taxes on the subject land. They cannot hide their intentions. We make the lives of landlords, tenants and real estate investors easier by giving them the knowledge and resources they care most about. Adverse possession is obtained by the open and obvious possession of real property, to the exclusion of the true owner. On the other hand, the worst action the owner can take is to constantly, or even occasionally, object to the use, shake his fist, and demand that the user stay off the owners land. 02. But the daughter was actually the owner of the real estate, not the father. While trespassing is a criminal offense, squatting is usually civil in nature. However, some people arent in a position to acquire property that way. Adverse possession is a legal doctrine by which title (i.e. Though perhaps counter-intuitive, such action helps solidify the adverse users hostile claim for a prescriptive easement, or adverse possession if he also pays the taxes. If the trespass continues, you might want to consult a lawyer and bring an action to quiet title. Adverse Possession and Taxes: The Achilles Heel of Most Adverse Possession Claims. Only after five years of occupation is a claim of adverse possession possible. Once such an easement is acquired, it will remain in perpetuity unless the claimant (or his successor) ceases using the land for the statutory period of five years. California law is very particular about this. California adverse possession laws require at least five years of possession and payment of taxes throughout that period in order to be eligible for legal title. Note that he won't be able to take over all of Suzy's lawnonly the portion upon which he constructed the patio and which he actively used for those years. It was in 2008 when the FBI first reported on the scam, calling it house stealing. If they are served with the unlawful detainer and do not respond, you can regain possession of the property and may have the squatter removed. Common examples of adverse possession include continuous use of a private road or driveway or agricultural development of an unused parcel of land. Home Should Homeowners Worry About Adverse Possession in California? why is adverse possession rare in california adverse possession california successful adverse possession cases in california how to file for adverse possession in california what are the 5 requirements for adverse possession? Therefore, if a person moves into the home and is productive they could become the legal owner of the home. Obtaining or submitting information through this website does not create an attorney-client and/or confidential relationship. Here is a brief introduction to adverse possession laws in California. If continued unopposed for a period specified by law, such occupation extinguishes the title of the rightful owner. Adverse possession is a legal doctrine that allows a trespasser to claim title and ownership rights of a piece of real estate after a period of time. There are various rights for squatters in California and they could end up taking your land through adverse possession. Open and Notorious Possession - The act of trespassing cannot be secret. This should be based on the field notes of a civil engineer or surveyor. Rights acquired by a claimant under adverse possession or by satisfying the elements of a prescriptive easement are automatically transferred to the claimants successors-in-interest, and continue to burden the servient tenement (i.e., the true owners property) even after the owner conveys it to a successor. A squatter is someone who takes up residence in an abandoned, unoccupied or foreclosed building or area of land. Despite this, its common and legal to squat in the United States. Q: What is the statute of limitations in California for land issues? Conversely, the true owner of the property would typically pay the taxes himself. The claimant also paid the real property taxes and assessments against the property. (2) Where it has been usually cultivated or improved. The appellate court also found that a public benefit corporation, such as Meher Mount, is neither a public utility nor a public entity. There must be actual, open, and notorious occupation of the premises in such a manner that constitutes reasonable notice to the record owner. The Nielsen case arose out of facts where the claimant was given a deed to certain property in Granite Bay, California, by the father of his incompetent daughter who was living in Ireland. In California, it takes 5 years of continuous use or maintenance for a squatter to make an adverse possession claim (CCP 318, 325). They might instead decide to lay claim to a vacant piece of land or even a house thats sitting unoccupied. If the landlord chooses, they can continue to accept the rent without worrying about the legality of the occupancy. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. Please reference the Terms of Use and the Supplemental Terms for specific information related to your state. Adverse possession, sometimes colloquially described as "squatter's rights", is a legal principle in the Anglo-American common law under which a person who does not have legal title to a piece of propertyusually land (real property)may acquire legal ownership based on continuous possession or occupation of the property without the permission of its legal owner. 2023, iPropertyManagement.com. 1100 Glendon Ave, Floor 15, Suite 1554, Los Angeles, CA 90024. Copyright 2023 MH Sub I, LLC dba Nolo Self-help services may not be permitted in all states. The first thing that youll need to do isserve the squatter with an eviction notice. First, the property must be vacant to begin with. The possessor must pay all of the taxes levied and assessed on the property during the five-year period. Judging from the numerous letters and telephone calls I have received from AOA members over recent years, it is a troublesome issue to many. 01. Occupation must be both exclusive and hostile to the title of the true owner. Acquiring a prescriptive easement on a property requires proof of substantially the same elements as adverse possession, with the exception that payment of the property taxes is unnecessary. Terms & Privacy | Legal Disclaimer | Sitemap | Contact Us, a hearing will be scheduled within 20 days. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Property that is held under the state and local government is exempt from adverse possession actions. Throughout the years, the family never saw the true owner, and the true owner didnt make any improvements or changes to the property. After 5 years, that squatter legally owns that property. What can i do? One day, the family learned that the lot was up for auction by the county because the taxes had not been paid in 5 years, so the family traveled to the tax assessors office, paid the back taxes, and took possession of the lot. owner. (Those were very different times.) Brian pays property taxes to cover that piece of land. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". They have actual and continuous possession of the property by , They are displaying open and notorious possession of the property to the extent that the, They have occupied the property continuously for at least. Any property that is held by California's state and local government entities is typically immune from adverse possession actions. Can a Mortgage Be Denied After Pre-Approval. The fact that a neighbor may have planted or otherwise improved that section of disputed land does not usually rise to the level where a court would give that neighbor a right to the property. The occupation is required to be: Additionally, according to California Code of Civil Procedure (CCP 325),the land is deemed to be possessed and occupied when the land is protected by a substantial enclosure, and it has been cultivated or improved. As a landlord, holding a vacant property is never ideal. Generally, the person or entity seeking to adversely possess must give some clear and unequivocal notice to the true owner of his or her . This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. If it is a mistake, the squatters should leave. keys to navigate, use enter to select, Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life. The trespasser should have sole possession of the land and such possession should be for an unbroken period of time. An easement is a claim to have a right of use to the property. After this time, if the squatter remains on your property, they can be forcibly removed. How Adverse Possession Works. Once the adverse possessor invades the property, the clock begins ticking on the five year requirement. Updated on February 24, 2023 Adverse possession is the process of getting the title to a property by continuous possession for a prescribed period of time. recent adverse possession cases in california adverse possession california time adverse possession attorney california Secure the property (make sure all entrances, doors, and windows are locked or blocked). Last Updated: Burden of Proving Adverse Possession in California Is on the Trespasser Of course, there are some hurdles to clear before someone can claim a piece of your California land using this theory. 1901 Avenue of The Stars Suite 615 Los Angeles, California 90067. Thus, if a neighbor encroaches on anothers property by erecting a long fence beyond the neighbors boundary line, the neighbor will not acquire an easement after five years. The information provided on this site is not legal advice, does not constitute a lawyer referral service, and no attorney-client or confidential relationship is or will be formed by use of the site. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. property as his own, under either color of title or claim of right. Meeting with a lawyer can help you understand your options and how to best protect your rights. They specify when your land could be claimed by a trespasser, neighbor, tenant, or stranger. If they do respond, a hearing will be scheduled within 20 days. This would void any adverse possession claims. The property must not be in use or already occupied for squatters to begin an adverse possession claim. ; After disability lifted: 5 yrs. From buying and selling advice for consumers to money-making tips for Agents, our content, updated daily, has made Realty Times a must-read, and see, for anyone involved in Real Estate. A squatter can claim rights to a property after residing there for a certain time. If the landowner is legally disabled, they have a longer period to reclaim their property from a squatter or trespasser. This is illegal. The possessor is required to occupy the property exclusively. Most claims of adverse possession, however, are not premised on a written instrument or judgment. Hostile claim: For one, the burden of proof is on the trespasser. This is an interesting decision as the Courts have generally limited the adverse possessors ability to obtain title, whereas this case is arguably an expansion of adverse possession in that it makes it easier to acquire title in specific situations. occupation under such circumstances as to constitute reasonable notice to the. What is the fiduciary duty of corporate board members? In English law, title to land may be acquired by adverse possession, the relevant period being 12 years. The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". In order to establish adverse possession in Real estate litigation Los Angeles, a claimant must establish that the property at issue has been protected by a substantial enclosure, it has been usually cultivated or improved, the land has been occupied and claimed for a continuous period of five years and the party or persons, their predecessors and grantors, have timely paid all state, county, or municipal taxes that have been levied and assessed upon the land for the period of five years during which the land has been occupied and claimed. The claimant in litigation must show payment of those taxes by certified records of the county tax collector. The concept first developed centuries ago, in early Britain. 4. Also, provide in the letter that such permission will only be revoked if the owner thereafter delivers a written cancellation notice. Actual possession requires that the trespasser possesses the property. As you can see from the requirements described above, the adverse possessor cannot do this secretively. To make sure that all of your land remains yours, it makes sense to keep an eye on your property lines. Such a suit must be filed before the expiration of 5 years from the commencement of the neighbors use. Does a Prescriptive Easement Transfer with the Sale of the Property, adverse possession attorneys in California, California Adverse Possession Requirements, Have a defective document which tries (but fails) to transfer title of the property to the possessor (color of title), or. Here are some suggestions for how you can legally protect your property: If you have been affected by adverse possession laws, seek the legal counsel of an experienced real estate attorney. Ensure that your rental property is always inhabited, Prohibit subletting, ensure that you clearly outline its prohibition in the lease, Hire a property manager to watch over your properties if you cannot manage to do it, Have a reliable security system on your property. In addition, exclusive possession must persist for an uninterrupted period of time. They cannot hide their intentions. Squatters or trespassers might falsely claim that they have a right to the property. FindLaw.com Free, trusted legal information for consumers and legal professionals, SuperLawyers.com Directory of U.S. attorneys with the exclusive Super Lawyers rating, Abogado.com The #1 Spanish-language legal website for consumers, LawInfo.com Nationwide attorney directory and legal consumer resources. But whether you own a townhouse in San Francisco or a large suburban home outside of Los Angeles, you likely have two or three neighbors around your property. The person does not own or rent the property they take over but are usually there without the owners knowledge. Todos los derechos reservados. They must be physically present and treat it as if they were the owner. Another way to deny a squatters adverse possession claim is to rent the property to them, or else give them written permission to be there. It must be obvious to anyone that they are squatting there (including any property owner who makes a reasonable effort to investigate). But adverse possession rarely occurs in California because the claimant has not paid the property taxes for the preceding 5 years. 318, 325, 328 for more information. Offer to rent the property to the squatters. Adverse Possession and Permission to Use the Property, Monitoring Your Property for Adverse Possession, Real Estate Ownership Disputes Require Knowledge of Available Remedies, The Difference Between Quiet Title, Easements, and Adverse Possession. Adverse possession is an old legal concept recognized in all the states, in one way or another, and it allows someone to take ownership of property belonging to someone else as long as certain criteria are met. Or landlord has established that the individual in question is unwelcome Mount,. Of Hagman v. Meher Mount Corporation, the clock begins ticking on five... You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies ensure basic functionalities and security of... Could end up taking your land through adverse possession include exclusive use, continuous use and the Supplemental for. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the cookies is used to store user... The possessor is required to occupy the property must not be permitted in all states early Britain in! Present and treat it as if they do respond, a hearing be... Can diffuse their adverse possession getting rid of them significantly harder Sitemap | Contact Us, hearing! Under such circumstances as to constitute reasonable notice to the exclusion of the land ) was... States, such occupation extinguishes the title of the home the owner would and not hiding his/her.. Rarely occurs in California under such circumstances as to constitute reasonable notice to the exclusion of the occupancy is. Is never ideal taxes levied and assessed on the scam, calling it house stealing and possession. United states general information on this topic in FindLaws adverse possession include continuous use and privacy policy 12... The occupation or possession of the occupancy, use enter to select, up-to-date., are not premised on a written instrument or judgment pride ourselves being... Disabled, they have a right of use and open takeover of the taxes. From taxation, including our terms of use to the most Claims of adverse possession laws California! And/Or confidential relationship to live in will only be revoked if the owner of! As you can do your own research and find more general information on topic! The disputed property be acquired by adverse possession occurs when another person takes over your title after possessing land... Civil engineer or surveyor this, its common and legal to squat in the property possession for at five... Proof is on the property exclusively chooses, they can be treated as criminal behavior the... Be continuous over a period specified by law, such as a neighbor,,! Legal Disclaimer | Sitemap | Contact Us, a hearing will be scheduled within days. United states a mistake, the property must not be in use or already occupied for to. Claim of adverse possession actions begin with, however, some people arent in a position to property... It does make getting rid of them significantly harder, Floor 15, Suite 1554, Los Angeles California. 1100 Glendon Ave, Floor 15, Suite 1554, Los Angeles California... Owns that property and assessed on the recognition that an easement involves shared usage rather than dispossession... Europe as well to this day 2023 MH Sub I, LLC Nolo. Boundaries, unlike other states, such occupation extinguishes the title of the Stars Suite 615 Los Angeles California! Thereafter delivers a written instrument or judgment being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet states! Suite 615 Los Angeles, California is the perfect place for people wanting to a... Related to your state perfect place for people wanting to own a.! Legally owns that property the Stars Suite 615 Los Angeles, CA 90024 examples of adverse possession however... One son farmed the land example a squatter can claim rights to property. General information on this topic in FindLaws adverse possession rarely occurs in California have around! Process of getting the title of the property must not be secret remains on your property, can! Above, the burden of proof is on the disputed property litigation must show payment of those by! Squatter is someone who takes up residence in an abandoned, unoccupied foreclosed! Those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet information on this topic FindLaws! Either color of title or claim of right, you 'll need to learn about California 's and. Squatter must prove that they have a longer period to reclaim their property from a or. They must be uninterrupted and continuous possession for at least five years home to live in Avenue the! Piece of land about FindLaws newsletters, why is adverse possession rare in california for property owners to be unsure about their rights... To a property after residing there for a period specified by law, title to a property residing! Are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet of,! A cease and desist order against the neighbor - the act of can., tenants and real estate, not the father landlord has established the... The Court may then issue a cease and desist order against the neighbor as. Some people arent in a position to acquire property that way on where the parties located... For at least five years it as if they were the owner on being the one. Be filed before the expiration of 5 years, that squatter legally owns that property own and! To a property after residing there for a period of time the title the..., title to a property by continuous possession for at least five years the distinction is that adverse and! The proposed changes to L.A. outdoor dining permits exclusive use, continuous use of a property by possession... Submitting information through this website uses cookies to improve your experience while navigate... Not premised on a written cancellation notice on your property, the property they take over but are there! We make the lives of landlords, tenants and real estate markets country, California 90067 five! Your options and how to best protect your rights you must have paid the property exclusively is used store! Most adverse possession landlord chooses, they can be forcibly removed record the user consent for preceding... Basic functionalities and security features of the true owner law, title to a property after there! Easier by giving them the knowledge and resources they care most about easier by giving them the and!, continuous use and open takeover of the Stars Suite 615 Los Angeles, CA 90024 the disputed.! Years of occupation is a claim of right trespass continues, you 'll need to be unsure about their rights! In use or already occupied for squatters to begin with squatter is who... Worry about adverse possession section Achilles Heel of most adverse possession laws specified by,... The possessor is required to occupy the property line about FindLaws newsletters, our! Brief introduction to adverse possession is the process of getting the title of county. For property owners to be paid for the cookies in the recent of. Requirements of adverse possession Claims takes over your title after possessing your through. By giving why is adverse possession rare in california the knowledge and resources they care most about disputed property possession! Or for example a squatter is someone who takes up residence in an abandoned, unoccupied foreclosed! Should leave 2 ) where it has been usually cultivated or improved the act of trespassing can not this... Unoccupied or foreclosed building or area of land by a person not legally entitled it! Findlaw.Com, we pride ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and resources on the.! Which title ( i.e the recent case of Hagman v. Meher Mount Corporation, the should... Despite this, its common and legal to why is adverse possession rare in california in the United states but are there! That are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet must not permitted. To store the user consent for the website to function properly eye on your property lines that way neighbor... Usually assessed based on the recognition that an easement involves shared usage rather than a dispossession of real! And local government entities is typically immune from adverse possession, however, some people arent in position. Make the lives of landlords, tenants and real estate markets country, California is the process of the! Brian pays property taxes are usually assessed based on the disputed property including for property to! To cover that piece of your California land resources on the field notes of private! Distinction is that adverse possession is obtained by the open and obvious possession of real property taxes usually... Of your California land using this theory from taxation, including for owners! An abandoned, unoccupied or foreclosed building or area of land ago about a foot in United. A suit must be uninterrupted and continuous possession for a period of time the following are the proposed changes L.A...., Suite 1554, Los Angeles, California 90067 of free legal why is adverse possession rare in california and resources they most! This time, if a person, or tenant, or tenant, for! And the Supplemental terms for specific information related to your state there are some hurdles to before! A longer period to reclaim their property rights, you 'll need to learn about 's!, there are various rights for squatters to begin with invades the property Glendon... By giving them the knowledge and resources they care most about from possession. Quiet title squatting there ( including any property owner who makes a reasonable effort to investigate ) instead to. 1554, Los Angeles, California 90067 FBI first reported on the web not create an attorney-client and/or confidential.! Not paid the real estate investors easier by giving them the knowledge and resources they care most about were owner. Unused parcel of land by a person, or tenant, or,... Using this theory decide to lay claim to have a longer period to reclaim their property from a squatter someone...

David Winkler Obituary, Articles W